Rowe Law Firm
We Return Phone Calls!
800-724-1992 Toll Free 225-250-1161 Local
Contact Our Firm

Bankruptcy cases raise issue of proper undue hardship test

In our last post, we spoke a bit about student loans and bankruptcy, particularly the difficulty of having student loan debt discharged in bankruptcy. As we noted, bankruptcy courts will not discharge student loan debt unless a debtor is able to demonstrate that paying of that debt would constitute an undue hardship. Very few debtors are able to successfully do that under current case law, but it is possible that this could change.

Most courts of appeal handling the issue of undue hardship apply a test which looks at whether a debtor is able to maintain a minimal standard of living if he or she is required to pay back student loans. If not, the court will recognize an undue hardship. The eight circuit court of appeals, though, utilizes test which looks at the totality of the circumstances when determining whether an undue hardship exists. The latter test is easier to pass. 

Two cases currently working their way through the appellate court system—one from the first circuit and another from the seventh circuit—could potential create an imbalance among the courts and draw attention from the Supreme Court.

The debate around the proper test for determining undue hardship is a complicated one, and the stakes are high, given the increasing number of grads with burdensome debt loads. Loosening up the requirements for discharging student loan debt in bankruptcy would bring relief to more grads, but the totality of the circumstances test still isn’t a free pass.

We’ll be keeping an eye on this issue, and will keep our readers apprised of any developments.


No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

  • Rowe Law Firm has always been there for me,
    without fail. Fast and efficient performance and
    reasonable prices keep my customers happy.

    - Jessie Clark, Hancock Bank - Testimonials
  • I found working with Rowe Law Firm to
    be a pleasure. I will be back.

    - Peggy Callihan, C.J. Brown Realtors - Testimonials
  • As an individual purchaser, I feel that I can
    trust Rowe Law Firm to make sure my closings
    are done right.

    - Charles Oliver, Architect - Testimonials

Broad Knowledge And
Extensive Experience

Over our decades of experience, we have successfully helped clients resolve a wide array of legal matters. Watch our videos to learn more about how we can help you.

Visit Our Video Center

Let Us Earn Your Trust.
Call For A Consultation.

At the Rowe Law Firm, we are proud that our clients can reach us when they need assistance. We always respond to phone calls promptly so you never have to struggle to reach your lawyer.

To learn more and schedule a consultation at our office in Baton Rouge, please send us an email by filling out our contact form. You may also call 225-250-1161 or 800-724-1992 toll free to speak with us about your case. We are eager to go to work for you.

Privacy Policy | Business Development Solutions by FindLaw, part of Thomson Reuters.

Back to top